Skip to main content

Summary Reader Response Draft 3

The article "Drones May Become 'The Next Big Thing' In Healthcare Delivery", written by Balasubramanian (2022), introduces the uses and impact drones have on the healthcare sector.  He started off the article by mentioning a real-life case study article by the European Heart Journal (2021), where the successful delivery rate of drones to Out-of-Hospital cardiac arrest patients was 92%. Through the advancement of drone technology, medical supplies such as Automated External Defibrillators (AED) will be able to arrive in a timely manner. Balasubramanian also discussed about an article by CISION PR Newswire (2022), when an elderly in Sweden suffered from cardiac arrest in December 2021 and it took just over three minutes for an AED to be swiftly delivered from the time the alarm sounded. To sum off, Balasubramaniam assert that with the promising future drones have, many sectors such as retail and military are also testing and researching to cater to their needs. With more users, the cost of drone technology will drop and this creates opportunities for more healthcare organizations to utilize drones at a more advanced stage and cheaper rate. 

In my opinion, drone technology has the capability to improve healthcare delivery through both transportation of healthcare supplies and acting as a platform for healthcare professionals to give accurate diagnosis and advice to patients during delivery. However, some critics may argue that it would not be sustainable due to weather conditions and flight regulations.

Drones can improve healthcare delivery through transportation of supplies such as vaccines and time crucial medical samples. According to Netscribes (2022), drones allow vaccines to be reachable for remote areas and this allows speedier vaccination administration especially for cases like the pandemic. This is likely because drones are airbounded and are able to fly at a high altitude avoiding resistance such as traffic jams and uneven terrains. According to Joshi who referenced from an article by Singh (2022), “Drones can zip over traffic” thus they can delivery twenty times faster than land delivery.  A report by Supply Chain (2022) claim that till this day, more than 220,000 doses have been successfully distributed overcoming challenges such as their low storage temperature. The report also mentioned that in Rwanda, drones owned by the company Zipline transported blood to 350 healthcare facilities and decrease wastage of 95%. This proves that as drones travel through air, it has lesser resistance to deal with compared to land delivery and thus is more efficient. It can be evident that drones reduced the wastage percentage for healthcare supplies and increased the success rate of healthcare supplies delivery thus made significant improvement to healthcare delivery.


Another capability of drones is their ability to act as a platform for healthcare professionals to give accurate diagnosis and advice to patients during delivery, in short telehealth. According to Southwick (2022), telemedicine diagnosis have an accuracy of 86.9% as compared to in-person diagnosis. The drones are equipped with cameras and display screens for communication between medical professionals and patient in their home (Balasubramaniam, 2022) and they are also of appropriate size to manuever around tight areas in houses (Miller, 2021). This gives healthcare professionals the flexibility of giving consultations without the need to travel. According to Miller (2021), this is necessary for patients during the pandemic as it acts as an in-person care especially for people who live alone. As healthcare experts are able to monitor the living and health conditions of patients, this allows them to be more precise in the medicine they prescribe and instruct the patients on the application of medicine. Therefore, through this 2 way communication method, healthcare delivery through drones would be more accurate. 

At the same time, it has its drawbacks which relates to weather conditions. According to Posea (2023), factors in the air such as wind, humidity and density can impact the flight as the drones only can withstand 13 to 18 mph of wind at most and it might consume more battery life to overcome the resistance. As there is more consumption of battery, there would be an increase in charging periods and down time. According to an article by UniEnergy Technology (n.d), flying drones in harsh conditions frequently drains the battery. As a result, drones would only be dispatched when there is optimal weather conditions otherwise their batteries would be damaged faster and the drones might even get lost. Since weather condition are unpredictable, the accuracy of timely delivery would be affected. 

Another downside would be flight regulations. According to Federal Aviation Administration News (2016, Small Unmanned Aircraft Systems section, para. 107.33), “allows unmanned systems up to 55 pounds to fly up to 400 feet, but they have to stay within visual line of sight.” This means that during the delivery of supplies, healthcare operators have to be around the drones and this would not be possible for delivery to rural areas. According to Civil Aviation Authority of Singapore (2023), the height restriction applies to areas such as No-fly zones and Unmanned aircraft flying areas which are mostly government buildings and parks. This implies that the drones might need to take an alternative route if it is unable to travel through restricted areas and this compromises the time and efficiency for delivery of critical supplies such as blood and vaccines. 

In conclusion, the use of drones contributes significantly to healthcare delivery through the transportation of supplies and the accurate diagnosis and advice for patients during delivery. As it is still a new and evergrowing technology, both weather and flight regulations are still big factors affecting the accuracy of delivery. Therefore, the advancement of technology will help accelerate the development of healthcare drones. 

References

Balasubramanian, S. (2022, Jan 9). Drones May Become 'The Next Big Thing' In Healthcare Delivery. Forbes. 

https://www.forbes.com/sites/saibala/2022/01/09/drones-may-become-the-next-big-thing-in-healthcare-delivery/?sh=9357ddd1e9b3

Civil Aviation Authority of Singapore. (2023, Jan 31). No-Fly zones and Unmanned  Aircraft Flying area. Civil Aviation Authority of Singapore.

https://www.caas.gov.sg/public-passengers/unmanned-aircraft/permitted-flying-areas-and-no-fly-zones

Cohen Healthcare. (n.d). Healthcare Compliance Issues for Medical Drones. Cohen Healthcare.

https://cohenhealthcarelaw.com/2022/10/healthcare-compliance-issues-for-medical-drones/

Everdrone AB. (2022, Jan 4). For the first time in medical history, an autonomous drone helps save the life of a cardiac arrest patient. Cision PR Newswire.

https://www.prnewswire.com/news-releases/for-the-first-time-in-medical-history-an-autonomous-drone-helps-save-the-life-of-a-cardiac-arrest-patient-301453744.html

Federal Aviation Administration. (2016, Jun 21). Summary of small unmmaned aircraft rule (Part 107). Federal Aviation Administration.

https://www.faa.gov/sites/faa.gov/files/2021-08/Part_107_Summary.pdf

Joshi, S. (2022, Jul 9). Faster Deliveries: Are Drones the Answer? Supply & Demand Chain Executive.

https://www.sdcexec.com/software-technology/emerging-technologies/article/22327025/fareye-faster-deliveries-are-drones-the-answer

Miller, M. (2021, Mar 15). New UC telehealth drone makes house calls. UC News.

https://www.uc.edu/news/articles/2021/03/virtual-medicine--new-uc-telehealth-drone-makes-house-calls.html

Netscribes. (2022, Feb 15). Drones in healthcare: The ‘next big thing’ for care deliver. Netscribes.

https://www.netscribes.com/drones-in-healthcare/

Posea, P. (2023). Can Drones Fly in Strong Winds? Dronesgator.

https://dronesgator.com/can-drones-fly-in-strong-winds/

Schierbeck el at. (2021, Aug 26). Automated external defibrillators delivered by drones to patients with suspected out-of-hospital cardiac arrest. European Heart Journal.

https://academic.oup.com/eurheartj/article/43/15/1478/6358076

Southwick, R. (2022, Sep 12). Telehealth diagnosis shows high level of accuracy, study finds. Chief Healthcare Executive.

https://www.chiefhealthcareexecutive.com/view/telehealth-diagnosis-shows-high-level-of-accuracy-study-finds

Supply Chain. (2022, Mar 14). Flying pharmacy: why medical drones will take off in 2022. Supply Chain.

https://www.here.com/learn/blog/medical-drones

UniEnergy Technologies. (n.d). How Long Does A Drone Battery Last? (Tips To Increase) UniEnergy Technologies.

https://www.uetechnologies.com/drones-battery-life/



 

 

 

 

Comments

Post a Comment

Popular posts from this blog

Descriptive Reflection: Self-introduction Letter

Dear Professor Brad My name is Michelle Tan and I am composing this introductory letter in hope that it allows you to get to know me better. I am currently pursuing engineering, at the Singapore Institute of Technology, as a Year 1 student under the sponsorship of the Singapore Armed Forces. Before furthering my degree, I graduated from Ngee Ann Polytechnic studying biomedical engineering, and was working as an Army engineer in the military. During my three years in the army, I ensured operationally ready armored tanks for combatants. I was tasked to repair faulty components, perform onsite maintenance (solving minor faults outfield without towing), and preventive maintenance of armaments such as mortars and guns. These experiences contributed to the development of my analytical skills for fault diagnosis and critical problem-solving skills for efficient onsite repairs to prevent delays in the training schedule. I chose to study engineering as it is a platform where I can put my sk
10 comments
Read more

The Importance of Communication Skills

Our understanding from Sherwyn Morreale, Michael Osborn & Judy Pearson, Professors of Communication (2000)'s quotation (3): Paul J Meyer gave a similar quote that  "Communication – the human connection – is the key to personal and career success.” Through these quotes, we derived that the importance of being competent at work revolves equal weightage between technical competency and communication.  How employers identify if graduates are able to communicate effectively would first be during the interviews, where there are forced to articulate their thoughts on the spot and present themselves. This proves if they have leadership through the confidence in their speech and teamwork as they interact with intellectual humility. As one have both of these skills, they will be able to obtain employment.  Being able to express their thoughts verbally and work through different points of view and arguments, one would significantly heighten their intellectual empathy. This would in t
2 comments
Read more

Critical Reflection

Module Learning At the start of the course, we were tasked to write up a descriptive reflection where I set my goals for the course to be improvement in two-way communication and writing skills with regards to tone and phrasing.  What impacted me the most was the Paul-Elder Framework where it educate me on the standards I should adopt when portraying an idea or even when working in a team. In this case, I usually will ask myself these questions for example: Do I have Intellectual Empathy? Am I having prejudice towards the idea or even the person that's why I am disagreeing with their viewpoint? Am I listening and understanding to my group mates' point of view and sharing? By thinking before I act out, I am able to clearly and accurately illustrate the idea I am sharing and also this gives time for my team mates to share their ideas too. This ticks the checkbox for the portion of wanting to improve my two-way communication skills because I give my team mates opportunities to sha
1 comment
Read more